What happens when three sisters who bicker through lunch every day think their mom has left the house?
In the story Sarah Rosensweet told me, they got along beautifully. And their mom heard the whole thing from inside the broom closet!
That story got me thinking about how often our kids want us to weigh in on who started it, who had it first, or who’s being unfair. To us, it’s a squabble over a toy. To them, it might feel more like, “Mom, whose side are you on?”
In part two of my Healthy Parenting Handbook conversation with Sarah, we get practical about what to do when sibling rivalry flares up. I play devil’s advocate a little (of course!) and ask what happens when you’ve already explained the rule and your kid grabs the toy anyway. Sarah gives us a question to ask ourselves in that moment. “What support does my child need to meet my expectation?”
We get into what that looks like with toddlers and teens, what to say when an older sibling goes into full parent mode, and how to make family dinner a time when your kids actually enjoy each other. And if you’ve ever looked back on a week and felt like you spent the whole thing as your kids’ secretary (Where’s your backpack? When’s practice?), Sarah leaves us with one small way to connect the very next time you see your child.
Love the Handbook?
Find all the episodes of the Healthy Parenting Handbook here, or listen on your favorite podcast player:
Don’t forget to leave us a review on Apple Podcasts too! Thank you!
Can't see the video? Watch on YouTube →
YouTube Shorts for This Episode
Key Takeaways about Sibling Rivalry
- When kids grab, hit, or pick a fight, start by assuming they want to do well. Hunger, tiredness, or a need for attention can make it harder to manage their reactions.
- Sometimes a child knows the rule and still grabs the toy. A young child may need you close by to help them pause and ask for a turn.
- Sarah calls the distance between what you expect and what your child can manage the “expectation gap.” Close it by asking what support would help your child follow through.
Attention is a vital need for children, just like food and sleep. – Sarah Rosensweet
- Teen sibling rivalry can show up as borrowing without asking or feeling outshone at school or in sports. Comparing siblings can make that competition worse.
- When one child starts policing another, they may be trying to show you they’re helpful. Acknowledge the effort and take over.
- A warm dinner table gives siblings a chance to enjoy each other. Save conflict talks for later and make room for everyone to share something from their day. Here are some of our family dinner rituals.
If somebody’s interested in peaceful parenting, but they don’t believe that a child actually wants to be good and is doing the best they can, they’re not going to be able to do this kind of parenting. – Sarah Rosensweet
Holiday Baking Challenge
Your kids might be hesitant about cooking, but I bet they love to help bake!
Give them what they want and get them into the kitchen baking pumpkin pie bars, homemade tortillas, pumpkin muffins, and more! Let it be a gateway to more cooking skills as they learn to crack eggs, roll out dough, and measure correctly.
Keep the access for yourself or gift it to a loved one this holiday season!
Check Out the Kids Baking Challenge Now!Action Steps from This Episode
- When a toy gets snatched, pause and ask yourself, “What does each child need right now?” Try offering a little one another toy or staying nearby during the next playtime.
- If your teen borrows a sibling’s sweater, try, “In our family, we ask before borrowing.” Then talk through how they’ll ask next time.
- If your teen feels outshone, talk privately. Try, “It sounds hard when hockey comes so easily to your brother. What’s that like for you?”
As humans, big or small, we’re terrible at figuring out what our needs are and asking for them to be met. – Sarah Rosensweet
- When a child steps into parent mode, say, “Thanks for trying to help, and I’ve got this.”
- At dinner, ask everyone to share the best part of their day or something they learned. If bickering is common, try a few minutes of one-on-one time before the meal.
- The next time you see your child, look up and smile before asking about homework, chores, or what time they need to leave.
Resources We Mention for Sibling Rivalry
- Get Sarah’s free training, “How to Stop Yelling at Your Kids” and get the “Stop Sibling Fighting” information on her resources page
- Family dinner rituals
- Disciple without Consequences – interview with Amy McCready of Positive Parenting Solutions
- How to raise siblings who love each other
- My episode with Sarah on The Peaceful Parent podcast
Turn expert advice into a handbook you can actually use.
I’ve interviewed hundreds of incredible experts on the Healthy Parenting Handbook podcast! Out of time to listen? You can skim on your phone!
These one-page summaries give you the highlights of every episode fast, so you can find what you need when you need it (and nothing to download).
100% privacy – You’ll also get Katie’s email newsletter with more practical tools for raising capable, confident kids. Change your preferences easily any time.





Leave a Comment